Tradition versus the heart (guest post)
By Bonnie Lundblad (my girlfriend)
Foreword (from Dan): This is, in part, a response to the now-infamous Christian video, “Why I Hate Religion, but Love Jesus.” While the basic idea of the video is good, Bonnie and I both had concerns over its message. To summarize, we feel as though it goes a bit overboard and extreme in the way it defines and characterizes religion, although the underlying message continues to carry some validity.
1 Then from Jerusalem came scribes and Pharisees and said, 2 Why do Your disciples transgress and violate the rules handed down by the elders of the past? For they do not practice [ceremonially] washing their hands before they eat. 3 He replied to them, And why also do you transgress and violate the commandment of God for the sake of the rules handed down to you by your forefathers (the elders)? 4 For God commanded, Honor your father and your mother, and, He who curses or reviles or speaks evil of or abuses or treats improperly his father or mother, let him surely come to his end by death. 5 But you say, If anyone tells his father or mother, What you would have gained from me [that is, the money and whatever I have that might be used for helping you] is already dedicated as a gift to God, then he is exempt and no longer under obligation to honor and help his father or his mother. 6 So for the sake of your tradition (the rules handed down by your forefathers), you have set aside the Word of God [depriving it of force and authority and making it of no effect]. 7 You pretenders (hypocrites)! Admirably and truly did Isaiah prophesy of you when he said: 8 These people draw near Me with their mouths and honor Me with their lips, but their hearts hold off and are far away from Me. 9 Uselessly do they worship Me, for they teach as doctrines the commands of men.
Verse 6 jumped out to me at first: “for the sake of tradition you have set aside God’s word.” This struck me as not only applying to the Pharisees or Jesus’ day, but also can be applied to many religions in today’s world, especially Christianity. How many people call themselves Christians and attend church ritually, but don’t read and follow the Bible? The Pharisees were very traditional, but they were so ritualistic that they missed the point. Verses 4-5 say the Pharisees were claiming to give what they have to God, but in doing so, they neglected their parents, which breaks one of God’s commandments. In trying to appear more holy through devoting all they had to God, they failed to keep the commandment about parents, thus doing worse through attempting to appear better.
Verse 8 and 9 is a quote from Isaiah 29:13. “These people draw near Me with their mouths and honor Me with their lips, but their hearts hold off and are far away from me” (verse 8). They worship God outwardly, but their heart is not in it. The way I see it in today’s world, there are Christians who do the same. Matthew 7:21 says that “not everyone who calls Jesus Lord will enter the kingdom of heaven.” Not everyone who appears Christian will actually be part of God’s kingdom. This verse always reminds me of Philippians 2:12, which says to “work out your salvation with fear and trembling.” I sometimes question my salvation and if my own heart is in it or if I am just following out of obedience. I have seen Christians in tears, one just a few days ago in fact, because they do not feel the love of God in their heart.
Allow me to elaborate on the heart. The heart referred to in Matthew 15:8 refers to the inward feelings and intensions. Just as love for a significant other cannot be explained, so is it with the love of God. The heart is that inward love for God that the verse references. The Pharisees make a show of their religion through the rituals and traditions handed down to them, but in their heart, they would rather have something else. I am guilty of this too. I have longed for sins that I know are against God, and have given in to those temptations even after being baptized. I have wanted the sin more than God. With God’s help, however, I am working hard to resist those temptations and put God in my heart in the places where desire for sin is being eradicated. I am declared righteous (in right standing with God), but I am still in the process of being sanctified (being made holy, or set apart). I think of sanctification as the state of being perfect. In my current state as a human living on earth, it is impossible to be perfect, but with God’s help in the process of sanctification, I can get closer and closer.
I know there are some Christians, especially the non-denominational ones, who think of religion as a bad thing. just look at the fact that they are called non-denominational… they do not want to call themselves a sect of religion. Religion itself isn’t necessarily bad, but unfortunately it has been corrupted in our day, just as the Pharisees had corrupted it in their day. Matthew 15:9 says “they teach as doctrines the commands of men.” The Pharisees did this in being so religious as to consider Jesus’ act of healing a man with a withered hand on the Sabbath bad because Jesus was working on the Sabbath. Jesus performed a miracle, yet was considered a sinner simply because of the day on which he did so! They corrupted the original meaning of scripture by lifting the Sabbath day up so much as to overlook the love your neighbor yet again.
I have heard some churches ignore the scripture they are supposed to be teaching in order to push their agenda. The particular instance that comes to mind is a year ago when I attended a Catholic service with a friend. Though there were hymns and scripture reading, the main sermon was about making sure your kids get into religious education. Where did the scripture go? Isn’t hearing God’s word what church service is about? (I have nothing against Catholics and know a handful who worship God even more because of the tradition they keep. This example is just an illustration of Matthew 15:9.)
I do not want to err in the same way the Pharisees did and follow a tradition without God’s word. I would rather follow God’s Word and have God in my heart. When the heart is good, the rest of the person will be good. All it takes is the proper object of the heart’s desire; that desire being for God.
Scripture quotations taken from the Amplified® Bible. Copyright © 1954, 1958, 1962, 1964, 1965, 1987 by The Lockman Foundation; used by permission.
